Wade Alliance

Leadership Consulting with a DEI lens

Balancing Mission and Margin

Jeff Hutchinson • December 13, 2021

During an interview I was once told “There is no mission without a margin” meaning that an organization must focus first on profit before it can fulfill its mission.
I respectfully cannot accept that. The choice is not a static picture of balance but a dynamic process of juggling.

More than 25 years of my career has been as an Army physician and putting profit over people is counter to the “mission first” world I grew up in. The minority of people who have served in the Armed Forces learn from the first day of Basic Training that we must do everything in our power to reach the objective. Mission failure is unacceptable.

Obviously, we are a part of an economy that depends on the exchange of goods and services while simultaneously expecting many things for free. My perspective despite this reality come from teaching Sunday School to second graders; the last time was in 2010. I was given course material and prepared each week for sixty to ninety minutes of crafts and conversations from young minds sometimes looking to learn. Each time I stepped into the room I was not being paid, I was not being recognized or compensated. Like the other volunteers, I saw the mission of teaching children as something I could and should do. Having taught hundreds of Sunday School lessons to children as part of a bigger mission reflected no regard for a margin.

A “margin first” view is easier to sell because of our inherent aversion to loss (Daniel Kahneman explains loss aversion). It is also rooted in a scarcity mindset believing that all resources are limited while ignoring the spectacular accomplishments achieved by people with limited capital and extraordinary purpose like two impactful organizations MEASURE  a data driven, community led non-profit and Black Speakers Collection a resource site to find Black speakers. Passion and purpose are obviously not enough knowing that the failure rate of small businesses according to the Bureau of Labor and Statistics is about 45% in five years but during the “Great Resignation” we are acknowledging that passion and purpose mean more.

The formula to success is not an equation. Instead of a static scale with weights placed reflecting priorities and resources, the better image to represent the interaction of mission and margin is of juggling. When finding new employees is now a challenge because of errors in leadership like firing people on a video call, money may not be enough to attract new talent. When employees are seen as resources and not essential components of success, retention and productivity is compromised.

Instead of “tips” to better juggle mission and margin consider these three questions:

1.      Do you measure how productivity relates to engagement?
Every organization measures productivity through sales, contracts, or units produced. Organizations are also starting to routinely measure climate and engagement through surveys and focus groups. Gathering useful data is difficult knowing that employee engagement affects productivity but people can also be engaged and not productive. An example of a useful metric is to identify employee volunteerism on committees, social activities or company sponsored charity events measured against their productivity benchmarks. The correlation may be enlightening.

2.    Can people outside of the C-Suite describe and discuss your mission?
Most people can easily describe their job and where the fit in the organization. The well worded mission and vision statement is often unknown to most employees in larger organizations. The sign in the break-room or the plaque over the door is not a substitute for regular conversations about everyone’s role in fulfilling the mission.

3.    Could you randomly select an employee to be in a commercial for your organization?
Not everyone is comfortable on screen but that is not the intent of the question. A culture where employees are the best recruiters represents a growing organization.

Profit will always be necessary for a successful business and there will always be overhead in running any business. Ignoring the importance of the mission and engagement has been a negligible cost for most business before 2020 but today the costs of ignoring engagement and mission may be the difference between thriving, adapting and growing or falling on the wrong side of the failure statistic.

Comments

By Jeff Hutchinson August 26, 2024
“All rules are equal but some are more equal than others” to paraphrase George Orwell’s pigs in Animal Farm.
A sculpture in Austin Texas with the word
By Jeff Hutchinson February 26, 2024
To evaluate our path to becoming a mission-driven individual there are six characteristics that we can use to evaluate our progress towards that goal.
By Jeff Hutchinson November 21, 2023
Evaluating a mission-driven organization
By Jeff Hutchinson April 5, 2023
Malcolm X's quote about partially removing a knife is not healing inspires a new analogy for racial harm. Racial harm is more like a bullet. It may be left in the body because it may cause more harm removing it. We also can start to heal even if the bullet remains.
Two models of figures dancing, one a Black woman in a red dress and blue hat, second a wooden figure
By Jeff Hutchinson December 3, 2022
The model minority myth is problematic it is used as a tool to help perpetuate racial hierarchies. Nigerian Americans as a group are successful but never seen as a model minority. The systemic racism that requires group ranking would break under the pressure of recognizing successful Black identifying groups like Nigerian Americans or HBCU graduates. There are individual and institutional paths to address stereotypes worth considering.
Drawer of messy wires
By Jeff Hutchinson July 19, 2022
Mental health is health. ( Trigger Warning - Suicide) Try these four techniques to help you through. 1. When the news of corrupt or self-serving people in power leave you feeling helpless, do something that you can control. Pick a junk drawer that you can tackle in one sitting and organize it. 2. Physical activity changes us physiologically and can help clear our thinking. 3. Be specific in what you are grateful for 4. Allow people to help you Cleaning out a junk drawer may be what you need to stop doom-scrolling.
Hand sanitizer and surgical mask
By Jeff Hutchinson April 5, 2022
We can provide protection physically, mentally, or emotionally based on our abilities and experience. The pleasure of protecting those we care about is undeniable, and the pain of seeing someone who is part of our group hurt is also palpable.
Man making his next move @rawpixel.com
By Jeff Hutchinson February 9, 2022
Great leaders share characteristics such as courage, persistence, vision and the ability to communicate and adapt. These are the exact qualities of an effective Chief Diversity Officer (CDO).
Stethescope and otoscope over a white coat
By Jeff Hutchinson January 11, 2022
In medicine we classify a problem as acute meaning that it recently happened or chronic for ailments that are at least 6 months old. This classification helps when trying to make a diagnosis and more importantly when thinking about what steps to take next. Racism is both an acute and chronic problem.
The leaky pipeline of women in science
By Jeff Hutchinson May 13, 2021
To increase the number of under-represented people in a field let's talk pathways not pipelines. Pipelines extract a resource that once lost can't be restored. A pathway has unlimited opportunities to succeed.
Show More
Share by: